Benke Defense Team Threatens Legal Action

By Rev. Jack Cascione

 

The Benke Defense Team at Benkedefenseteam@aol.com (A. K. A. Don Matzat) is requesting the identity of email participants on Lutheran Quest.

They are asking that the identity of Internet users be sent to:

Alan R. Pollack

APollack@capvish.com

Capell & Vishnick, LLP
3000 Marcus Avenue
Lake Success, NY 11042
516-437-4385 ext. 116
Fax: 516-437-4395

Evidently, these are Benke's attorneys in New York. We can assure all Luther Quest users and Reclaim News recipients that no one's name, identity, or email is going to be turned over to any law firm or anyone else for any reason at any time. The Benke Defense Team gave no reason why they wanted the identities of these Internet users.

At this time the Benkedefenseteam@aol.com is no longer a working email address.  We believe the Benke Defense Team is attempting to threaten, harass, and silence those who publicly agree with Dr. Wallace Schulz's decision to suspend Benke.
Benke, an LCMS District President, was one of many clergy who offered public prayers along with pagan clergy at Yankee Stadium.  At no time in the Bible did Christ or any of the Apostles include their prayers with pagan prayers. Many in the COP, as well as the Synodical President, now seek to pray in public with pagan clergy.

In response to any lawsuit file by "The Benke Defense Team" the first two depositions will be taken from Dr. Gerald Kieschnick and Dr. David Benke.  In 1989, when Dr. Alvin Schmidt sued us over charges that he was promoting woman ordination, the Synod bought off (de-indemnified) our insurance company before we could depose President Ralph Bohlmann.  Schmidt filed a 128-paragraph suit in Allen County, Indiana, naming Robert Preus, Jack Cascione, Fort Wayne, and the LCMS.  Our insurance carrier, "Church Mutual" stopped defending the case once the Synod promised to pay all costs.  The LCMS Board of Directors paid Schmidt an estimated $40,000.00 to drop his case.

Let's see what happens this time.

August 30, 2002