Without Faith, Christian Doctrine Divides Churches and People

By: Rev. Jack Cascione

In the following quotations, Luther shows that Christian doctrine is detrimental to faithless congregations or congregations that are weak in faith.  Many pastors quickly learn that watering down the doctrinal content of their sermons is good for their job security and the numerical growth of their congregation.

Make them feel good, try to keep the sermon interesting and current, but go light on the doctrine, or the church could break into lots of tiny pieces. One will be offended by this and another will object to that.

Of course, if the congregation has faith in God's Word and has over the years been built on a steady diet of Christian doctrine, the people will be increasingly strengthened and united by doctrinal preaching.  If they have faith, they will grow like a crystal instead of being shattered like glass.



"For commandments do not make anyone better, in fact they make everyone worse."  LW13:5


"But the Gospel and the proclamation of God's name in Christ do construct a solid highway, for faith furnishes a good foundation and dries out every foul march of the wicked flesh.  And now Christ rides on them; that is, He performs in them His works, which are love, joy, peace, kindness, meekness, chastity (Gal. 5:22).  Let us note the word 'ride.'  He does not stand still; for the life in faith implies progress, a walk or journey toward heaven into another life."  LW13.5


"Apart from faith, all doctrine and life separate and disunite mankind.  The formation of sects is the inevitable result, even though there may be only two persons in a house.  For their whole existence revolves about externa lworks and ways, which will necessarily be varied.   You will find one abounding in this prayer, one in that.  One is a Carthusian monk, or a barefoot friar.  One goes on pilgrimages, one endows institutions, one fasts.    If hearts cling to any of these, discord, hatred, pride, and all sorts of misery will surely follow.  Therefore there is no god, no doctrine, no life, no means that produces unanimity other than this God with His agency of faith.  This faith draws us all into the Spirit; there all things are harmonious, and all external difference disappear.  This does not imply that no external differences remain; it merely means that the heart does not cling to these, that these do not set one person against the other, even if the whole world dwelt together under one roof.

First of all, however, it is imperative that man be taken captive by the Law and be placed into the bondage of sin, that is in terror of his conscience. He who feels no sin will not be impelled to seek grace; he will pay no attention either to the Gospel or to faith.  Therefore the Law is conscience, jailer, chains, fetters, and prison.  The Law points to sin and exposes it, and thus it takes conscience captive (Rom 4:17; 7:7,8). God does not deliver us from these bonds whenever we deem it necessary, but He
permits us to be humbled and tormented in them until we thirst for grace. Now He comes and gives us His Word, to which we cling, and leads us out of captivity.  Thus we escape a terrified and despondent conscience, and we get a good and sure conscience.  That is the twofold work and performance of Christ in us: and He exalts us, each in His good season; this indicated by the two pillars in the desert, the pillar of cloud and the pillar of fire." (Ex. 13:21, 22). LW13:7-8


"Where God does not provide the message, a sermon is useless." LW13:12


"Since faith alone purifies from sin, as St. Peter says in Acts 15:9, and since faith is dependent solely on God's Word, no one can preach the Word of God unless he is sent by God, as St. Paul teaches in Romans 10:15.  From this it must follow that all man-made doctrine is injurious and renders a person unclean and coal-black." LW13:16

November  4, 2002