California Conservatives Prepare For 2004 LCMS Convention Crisis

(corrected version)

By: Rev. Jack Cascione

(Corrected: A misplaced sentence in the first release changed the entire direction of the article.  This is the Corrected release.)


Planning and strategy meetings for the 2004 LCMS Convention are now taking place throughout the Synod.

Recent rulings by the LCMS Commission on Constitutional Matters have raised the authority of the LCMS President to a virtual Lutheran papacy.  The direction of the Synod will now be determined by who is elected President. In other words, the Synod has evolved into a one vote, winner-take-all Convention.

Just as Walther, the Synod's founder prophesied, once a church body is no longer governed by doctrine, the real issue is the arrangement of the chairs.

While in California, on Wednesday February 9, 2003, this writer met with "Affirm," "Balance," "Consensus" and "Lutheran Concerns" operatives in four locations.

Last year it was assumed that Rev. Daniel Preus will be the conservatives' candidate but I was rather surprised to learn how much support there is for Robert Kuhn.  It now appears that if Kuhn chooses to allow his name to stand for election, he is the most likely conservative candidate for the LCMS Presidency.

Kuhn has served as a District President, Synodical Vice President, Acting LCMS President, and is currently Chairman of the LCMS Board of Directors. There isn't anyone close to his qualifications.  The question is, "Will he allow his name to stand for election?"  He withdrew his name from consideration in 2001.  However, conditions in the Synod are in near chaos and Kuhn has the skills to put the fire out.

The finances of the LCMS are a disaster.  The current LCMS President desperately needs the support of the Synod's District Presidents (COP) to be reelected.  But the unbridled growth of District bureaucracies is bankrupting the Synod, cutting teacher colleges and seminaries down to an abysmal 1% of Synodical support, and causing the recall of nearly 1/4 of all LCMS foreign mission workers. Kieschnick will not demand that Districts send 80% of all resources received by the Districts to the Synod.

The tragedy is, there are more than enough funds given to Synod but in 2003 the Districts kept approximately $100,500,000 for themselves and only sent $24,293,120 to the Synod.  In other words, the Districts kept 80 cents of every dollar they received.  The District Offices have become the Synod's highest priority and mission.

While speaking at First Lutheran Church in the San Fernando Valley, I pointed out that the Pacific South West District (PSWD) typified the greed that is now destroying the LCMS.

According to page 728 of the 2003 Lutheran Annual, the PSWD received $7,192,687 but only sent $200,000 to the Synod in 2001.  On page 58, the PSWD lists 14 paid staff, not counting secretaries and other workers.  In 1961, the PSWD's District President was a full-time parish pastor but things have changed.

Like many Districts the PSWD has placed its own agenda above the human souls around the world that need to hear the Gospel.  Few members in the pew realize their offerings are making life very pleasant for the District elite.

The day will come when Loren Kramer and Larry Stoterau and the self-serving clergy who reelect them will have to give an account for what they did with the church offerings in their hands.

February 12, 2003