Fort Wayne:
Long on Form But Short on Polity?
By Rev. Jack Cascione

 

The Fort Wayne Seminary publication used to be Called to Serve.  The lead article of the October 1999 issue of Life of the World is now titled, "Called & Ordained" by Rev. Chad Bird.

The front cover shows what appears to be four seminarians, in chasubles and albs, two holding candles, one holding an open Bible, and the fourth with properly placed thumbs and open raised palms reading the Bible from the aisle between the pews.

The purpose of this beautiful 24-page magazine with 30 glossy photographs is to generate interest from prospective students for the ministry and support for the Seminary.

Why do they think that such a photograph described above or another showing the proper placement of hands near the communion elements on the altar or another full-page color shot of the proper grip on a processional cross will attract students to the Seminary? What is the intended market profile here?

The second paragraph of the lead article states: "Raised eyebrows and wrinkled foreheads, however, are the characteristic reactions to the suggestion that the office of the Holy Ministry is also a priestly vocation whose occupants may rightly be called priests."

According to 1 Peter 2:9 every baptized child is a priest of God. Doesn't that make every honorable vocation a priestly vocation? However, in order to be a pastor, a congregation must call a priest of God into the Office of the Ministry. Why has the emphasis shifted from Seminary graduates seeking calls from congregations to whether or not the pastors should be called priests? In other words, so what!

If Fort Wayne wants to emphasize the reality of the pastoral office why, not show a Circuit Counselor running a call meeting as a room full of Voters looks over the names of the candidates, on one of whom they will confer the pastoral office. Calls don't grow on trees. They go to qualified candidates with or without chasubles.

The article goes on to compare the Old and the New Testament Priesthood. The first sentence under "Conclusion" reads: "The priestly character of the New Testament ministry is rooted in and flows from the priestly office of the One who speaks and acts through those called and ordained."

I disagree. Christ speaks and acts through the Word and Sacraments regardless of the faith or faithlessness of the pastor. There has been a shift here from the pastor properly being an ambassador to an emphasis on the pastor as God's conduit endowed with the spiritual attributes of the priestly office of the Holy Ministry. Is the author implying that the pastor receives spiritual gifts when he receives the sacrament of ordination?

President Wenthe correctly defines the problems of consumerism and market driven manipulation energizing the Church Growth Movement in his opening message. But has Fort Wayne over-reacted by stressing veiled sacerdotalism as the antidote to Wal-Mart theology.

There is an excellent article in the magazine titled, "The Gospel Ministry in the Lutheran Confessions." However, stressing that "everything must be done in love" does not suffice as a substitute for the specific articles of a congregational constitution.

Their students seem to have the proper grip on the processional cross, the proper stance in front of the open Bible, and the proper positioning of the hands by the communion elements. Have they also been instructed on the proper form of an LCMS congregational constitution and the need for Voter supremacy in all LCMS congregations? Are they aware of how to deal with the Voters who "called and ordained" them and the importance of practicing Walther's Church and Ministry in every LCMS congregation?

Yes, the Church Growth/ PLI barbarians are at the gate. The COP unanimously endorses and funds Dr. Norbert Oesch's "Pastoral Leadership Institute" without approval of the LCMS Convention. With this support the COP has laid down its cross and many of its members are in real danger of eternal damnation. They have traded the work of the Holy Spirit for the mammon of statistical results in the Church of Christ. The St. Louis Seminary President has endorsed PLI and has placed his own soul in jeopardy.

Has the chaos at the ramparts caused Fort Wayne to give up Walther's Church and Ministry and Voter supremacy as the only acceptable polity in the LCMS?

The question is, who does the calling and ordaining and what are the duties of those called and ordained to the people who called and ordained them? If I have misread their publication I'm sure Fort Wayne can defend itself by simply saying that Walther's Voter supremacy is the only polity it endorses and teaches to its students. Such an affirmation would illuminate the slightest hint of sacerdotalism.


Rev. Jack Cascione is pastor of Redeemer Lutheran Church (LCMS - MI) in St. Clair Shores, Michigan. He has written numerous articles for Christian News and is the author of Reclaiming the Gospel in the LCMS: How to Keep Your Congregation Lutheran. He has also written a study on the Book of Revelation called In Search of the Biblical Order.
He can be reached by email at pastorcascione@juno.com.

November 22, 1999