Luther: On True Worship Before the Fall
(Part IV)
By Rev. Jack Cascione

 

Continued from "Luther and the Presence of God in the Genesis Commentary: Did Luther Change? (Part III)"

The often-groundless views of worship in America are contrasted here with the views of the founder of the Lutheran Reformation. Luther addresses the questions: Why is there worship? Did Adam worship? Did Adam have to go to church? Who was the preacher? In the context of life before the fall into sin what was worship like? It didn't last that long, yet, nevertheless there was true worship.

More than the subject of "Church and Ministry," Luther wrote on the more practical subject of true worship. What could be truer about worship than worship before the fall into sin? In view of the corruption of worship by Pope, the "late" Luther (1535-1545) was engrossed in the subject of true worship.

Luther may have been the first author to write so extensively on worship before the fall into sin. All that Luther has to say about worship, and there is a great deal, must be predicated on his understanding of worship before the fall into sin. Needless to say, after the fall, the character of worship changed.

Luther's thoughts about worship are focused on Genesis 2:3 "And God blessed the seventh day and sanctified it, because on it He had rested from all His work, which God created, so that He made it."

God made the Sabbath for man

Luther quotes Matthew 12 and Mark 2 to support his interpretation of Gen. 2:3 that God made the Sabbath for man before the fall into sin. "For the Son of man is Lord even of the Sabbath day." (Matthew 12:8) "And he said unto them, The Sabbath was made for man, and not man for the Sabbath: 28 Therefore the Son of man is Lord also of the Sabbath." (Mark 2:27-28)

Luther points out that Moses doesn't say anything about man in Gen. 2:3 but that God blessed the Sabbath and sanctified it for Himself. This means the Sabbath is set aside for divine worship.

The seventh day was made holy by God till the end of time

Luther makes no comment about the necessity of which day is chosen for worship as long as it is once every seven days.

"This has the special purpose of making us understand that the seventh day in particular should be devoted to divine worship. For "holy" is that which has been set-aside for God and has been removed from all secular uses. Hence to sanctify means to set aside for sacred purposes, or for the worship of God. In this manner Moses rather frequently employs the expression, also of sacred vessels." (LW1:79)

Adam would have always kept the seventh day holy

"It follows, therefore, from this passage that if Adam had remained in the state of innocence, he nevertheless would have held the seventh day sacred. That is, on this day he would have given his descendants instructions about the will and worship of God; he would have praised God; he would have given thanks; he would have sacrificed, etc. . . Indeed, even after the Fall he kept this seventh day sacred; that is, on this day he instructed his family, of which the sacrifices of his sons Cain and Abel give the proof. Therefore from the beginning of the world the Sabbath was intended for the worship of God." (LW1:79)

The human race was intended to be immortal as proven by the command to worship

"Moreover, this also implies the immortality of the human race, as the Letter to the Hebrews (8:11) learnedly expounds concerning God's rest on the basis of Ps. 95:11: 'They shall not enter into My rest.' For God's rest is eternal. Adam would have lived for a definite time in Paradise, according to God's pleasure; then he would have been carried off to that rest of God, which God, through the sanctifying of the Sabbath, wished not only to symbolize for men but also to grant to them. Thus the physical life would have been blissful and holy, spiritual and eternal." (LW1:80)

The Sabbath command remains for the church

"Now we wretched men have lost that bliss of our physical life through sin, and while we live we are in the midst of death. And yet, because the Sabbath command remains for the church, it denotes that spiritual life is to be restored to us through Christ. And so the prophets have carefully searched those passages in which Moses intimates the resurrection of the flesh and life immortal." (LW1:80)

Man is created for worship

"Then it is also shown here that man was especially created for the knowledge and worship of God; for the Sabbath was not ordained for sheep and cows but for men, that in them the knowledge of God might be developed and might increase." (LW1:80)

The Seventh day is set-aside for the Word of God

"On the seventh day He wanted men to busy themselves both with His Word and with the other forms of worship established by Him, so that we might give first thought to the fact that this nature was created chiefly for acknowledging and glorifying God." (LW1:80)

The Existence of God's Word proves eternal life

"Moreover, this is also written that we might preserve in our minds a sure hope of the future and eternal life. All the things God wants done on the Sabbath are clear signs of another life after this life. Why is it necessary for God to speak with us through His Word if we are not to live in a future and eternal life? If we are not to hope for a future life, why do we not live like people with whom God does not speak and who do not know God? But because the Divine Majesty speaks to man alone and man alone knows and apprehends God, it necessarily follows that there is another life after this life; to attain it we need the Word and the knowledge of God. For this temporal and present life is a physical life, such as all the beasts live that do not know God and the Word." (LW1:80)

"Therefore that God gives His Word, that He commands us to occupy ourselves with the Word, that He issues orders for sanctifying the Sabbath and for His worship-and this clearly proves that there remains a life after this life and that man was created not for this physical life only, like the other animals, but for eternal life, just as God, who has ordered and ordained these practices, is eternal." (LW1:81)

The seventh day is for preaching

"Early in the morning of the seventh day, which had been sanctified by the Lord, God speaks with Adam, gives him directions concerning His worship, and forbids him to eat the fruit of the tree of the knowledge of good and evil. This is the real purpose of the seventh day: that the Word of God be preached and heard. Henceforth both in the Scripture and in common usage the practice remained that the morning time was set aside for prayer and preaching, as Ps. 5:3 says: 'In the morning I shall stand before Thee, and I shall see.'" (LW1:81)

The Tree of Knowledge was to be the center of Adam's Worship

"Today in our churches we have an altar for the administration of the Eucharist, and we have platforms or pulpits for teaching the people. These objects were built not only to meet a need but also to create a solemn atmosphere. But this tree of the knowledge of good and evil was Adam's church, altar, and pulpit." (LW1:95)

"So, then, this tree of the knowledge of good and evil, or the place where trees of this kind were planted in large number, would have been the church at which Adam, together with his descendants, would have gathered on the Sabbath day." (LW1:105)

Adam worshiped God by obeying the command not to eat from the Tree

"Therefore let us learn that some external form of worship and a definite work of obedience were necessary for man, who was created to have all the other living creatures under his control, to know his Creator, and to thank Him." (LW1:95)

". . . while the tree of the knowledge of good and evil is forbidden, the outward worship of the future church is established by divine authority-the worship in which they would have borne witness of their obedience to God if they had avoided the devil's snares." (LW1:140)

"The tree was not poisonous; but, as we said above at great length, it was a tree of divine worship, for man to bear witness through his obedience that he knew, honored, and feared his God. For God saw that everything He had made was very good." (LW1:227)

The Tree was Gospel and Law

"'For the complete text reads (1 Tim. 1:9-10): "The Law has not been given for the just person, but for murderers, adulterers, etc.' From this there follows nothing else than that Paul is speaking about that Law which was given after sin, and not about this Law which the Lord gave when Adam was still guiltless and righteous. For the righteous, he says, no Law was given; therefore it follows undeniably that the Law was given to wicked and sinful nature." (LW1:108)

"'The Word which the Lord had spoken to Adam was: "Do not eat from the tree of the knowledge of good and evil.' For Adam this Word was Gospel and Law; it was his worship; it was his service and the obedience he could offer God in this state of innocence." (LW1:146)

Note: The reference "Luther's Works" and "LW" in all quotations and the body of this article refer (via volume and page number(s)) to the American Edition of Luther's Works, jointly published by Fortress Press and Concordia Publishing House.


Rev. Jack Cascione is pastor of Redeemer Lutheran Church (LCMS - MI) in St. Clair Shores, Michigan. He has written numerous articles for Christian News and is the author of Reclaiming the Gospel in the LCMS: How to Keep Your Congregation Lutheran. He has also written a study on the Book of Revelation called In Search of the Biblical Order.
He can be reached by email at pastorcascione@juno.com.

March 2, 2002